This site is intended for health professionals only

Read the latest issue online
Winter work


Children conceived by infertility treatment more prone to mental health problems, study finds

Children conceived by infertility treatment more prone to mental health problems, study finds
Getty Images, RF

Children conceived through infertility treatments are more likely to have mental health problems by their late teens, according to a new study led by researchers at University College London (UCL) and the University of Helsinki.

The researchers examined the link between medically assisted reproduction (MAR) techniques such as IVF treatment, artificial insemination and ovulation induction and young people’s educational outcomes and mental health. They compared the findings with children conceived naturally.

Children conceived by MAR were found to do better at school, were less likely to drop out and were at a lower risk of not being in education or employment or leaving home early compared to naturally conceived adolescents. These differences disappeared when family circumstances were considered, suggesting that socioeconomic background is essential in explaining this advantage.

However, the increase in mental health issues for children conceived by MAR was found to be independent of socioeconomic background and unrelated to the MAR technique.

Previous studies mainly focus on birth or early life outcomes, and very little is currently known about the impact of MAR on older children. These new findings are published in the European Journal of Population.

To examine links between MAR and educational and mental health outcomes, the researchers analysed the administrative records of 280 682 Finnish adolescents aged between 16 and 18. The children were born between 1995 and 2000, with 266 925 being conceived naturally, whilst 13 757 were conceived through MAR.

When family circumstances were considered, adolescents conceived via MAR were at an increased risk of developing a mental disorder, particularly anxiety or depression.  Although the difference was slight, around 10 percent of MAR-conceived adolescents compared to nine percent of naturally conceived adolescents received a mental health diagnosis between ages 16-18, the researchers stated the difference could be a cause for concern.

Dr Hanna Remes from the University of Helsinki said: ‘Whilst we don’t have the data to explain why those born by medically assisted reproduction are at slightly higher risk of mental health disorders, we believe that this may be due to different mechanisms.’

‘It is possible that because of the process they went through, parents of children conceived by IVF, for example, may have been exposed to mental health problems, such as depression and anxiety, which may, in turn, have put the children themselves at higher risk of having mental health problems.

‘Alternatively, they may be more apprehensive about their child’s welfare and more likely to make sure their child attends hospital or visits the doctor – and therefore these children may be more likely to get a diagnosis for certain conditions.’

With the oldest child conceived by IVF being 43 years of age and the rise in the number of children being conceived via MAR, the researchers suggest that it is vital to understand the longer-term consequences on children and young people

This comes after experts warned last week that the impact of smoking on mental health  is no longer in doubt, and should be addressed by government policy.

Complete relevant Mental health CPD modules on Nursing in Practice Learning by registering for free, or upgrade to a premium membership for full access at only £29.95 a year.

See how our symptom tool can help you make better sense of patient presentations
Click here to search a symptom

Visit Nursing in Practice Reference for details on 140 symptoms, including easily searchable symptoms and categories, offering you a free platform to check symptoms or search by category during a consultation to look for guidance on next steps.